The Scruffy Trader Arvostelua 

I booked a one-hour coaching session with Scruff and ended up getting far more value than I expected, which is saying something because I was already expecting a lot of value based on his YouTube videos and being part of the group.

Right from the start, he made it clear not to worry about the clock and took the time to properly understand where I was in my trading journey and what I was struggling with.

The session felt very tailored rather than generic. He focused on helping me understand how to think about the market properly, build a bigger-picture view, and approach trading with structure and patience, rather than just handing over a basic “buy here, sell here” strategy.

He checked throughout that everything made sense, encouraged questions, and made it clear there is no such thing as a stupid question.

The session was recorded and he sent over a detailed summary afterwards, which means I can go back through everything and keep learning from it. Overall, I came away with much more clarity, confidence, and a proper framework for improving.

Really good experience and genuinely valuable coaching. I would highly recommend it if you are considering it.

Thanks again, Scruffy.

I’ve been interested in trading for multiple years now, and honestly, I threw away the first couple of them because of bad education.

The industry is full of emotional nonsense, and people selling shortcuts that don’t actually work, so finding real, skill based education is very difficult.

When I came across Gary, that finally changed. He’s genuinely the only person I’ve seen, especially on YouTube, who shows what proper day trading actually looks like. He doesn’t sell hype or emotions. He shows how someone with real skill looks at the market, makes decisions, and operates day to day.

What really separates him from everyone else is transparency. He shows and explains how he trades in real time, every single day. Puts his head on the block and explains what he’s looking at, how he views the market, what his plan is, and why. Then he follows through with it. There’s no rolling back charts, no “I got in here, I got out there” after the fact.

There is no chopping and changing strategies or chasing new ideas. Everything is based on common sense and years of experience. You can tell this comes not just from trading his own money, but from time spent in the professional industry.

On top of that, he’s a genuinely good guy. Gary is amazingly patient, always willing to answer questions, and will sit with you and help you just for the sake of helping. There’s no pressure, no false promises, and no ego involved. He doesn’t really get anything in return from it, he just wants people to learn properly and looks after the people in the squad wanting to learn.

In the squad itself and on the youtube platform there’s a massive amount of content available, ranging from very detailed walkthroughs to mindset to management, etc. Material aimed at the different aspects that have to fall into place for a trading framework to work.
There’s no “X marks the spot” nonsense and no lifestyle marketing. You won’t see glossy Lambos or expensive watches. You’ll get exactly what you need to become a better trader: real world trading, discipline, and common sense.

If you actually want to learn the skill properly and see how a genuinely skilled trader operates every day, this is the right place.

Thank you very much for all your work, Gary!

All the best,
Alba

I was waiting to get funded before writing an honest review of Scruffy.

Following "The Way of the Scruff," I got funded with a $5K account in two months — an 86% win rate on my first evaluation, 79% on my second, and max drawdown under 1.2%.

I came to Scruffy a little over a year ago. I started studying all the modules in "The Way of the Scruff" while also trading some prop firm accounts in parallel. I made progress, but felt it was too slow to get funded, so I switched to other YouTube channels promising you could pass a prop account in under a week. Result: blown account.

It never made sense to me that you could be profitable winning only 30% of the time (losing 70%). Maybe that math works if you're only risking a prop firm's capital, but losing 70% of trades with my own money sounded crazy.

I also couldn't validate some of the more esoteric concepts, like the Fair Value Gap. The theory is that an FVG forms because price moved so fast that buyers/sellers couldn't get their orders filled — but I'd see an FVG on the 1-hour chart, and it would shrink on the 15-minute chart and disappear entirely on the 5-minute chart. So buyers and sellers were executing orders the whole time; it just wasn't visible at the higher timeframe.

Using Scruffy's framework, on the other hand, you learn to identify areas of interest — where price is likely to reverse, stall, or break through — and how to minimize losses when a trade doesn't go your way. The high win rates aren't because you're risking far more than you stand to earn; they come from analyzing the market before entering a trade and following a controlled exit methodology.

Scruffy doesn't teach a trading strategy — he teaches a trading framework. He doesn't focus on hitting a certain risk/reward ratio, but on the amount you should expect to earn relative to your investment. You learn that slow, steady earnings will take you further than chasing 1-2% wins.

He teaches you to respect the profession — to trade a prop firm account the same way you'd trade your own capital. He teaches you to become a professional trader, not a gambler.

I could go on and on, but I'll just say: thank you, Gary.

I’ve been trying to find a real way to approach and understand the markets for the last seven years. Like a lot of traders, I watched countless YouTube videos, jumped from strategy to strategy, which looking back, was 100% my own fault.

What stands out with Scruffy Trader is the consistency in the way he breaks down the charts and explains market behaviour day after day after day. There’s no hiding behind hindsight or vague theory. He puts himself on the line live, explains what he is seeing, and does it repeatedly.

The group itself is also excellent. People will post opinions and/or ask questions around certain setups, and Scruff will break them down in detail so you can actually understand the thinking behind the move, not just the result.

For me, that’s the biggest difference.. the level of transparency, structure and consistency.

He shows up every day and delivers. Honestly, what more could you want...

Highly recommended, dont ask for signals but participate

Scruffy is the most honest one out there if you want to learn to trade. The amount of time and effort he puts in to try and help people succeed is incredible, and I wish more people would appreciate everything he does. He won't sell dreams, won't give signals and won't give shortcuts, just good, honest advice on what trading is really about. At the end of the day, trading is a job and it should be treated like a career change. It requires work and effort, and takes time to learn. I've gone through the Way of the Scruff modules and I now have a good understanding of the theory behind it. I just need to put it into practice now and start small. I've done this around working a full time job so it's taken a while, but it'll be worth it in the end. There really is no other way to learn this, and Scruff will tell you exactly how it is while injecting his own style of humour. If you're willing to learn and put the effort in, then this is definitely for you. If you want quick riches and a lambo, then carry on watching the others on Tik Tok and YouTube and keep dreaming, because that's not the reality.

I had been considering booking a one-to-one session for a little while. After speaking to a few others who had already had a session and highly recommended it, I decided to make use of a discount code and book one for myself.

Before the meeting, Gary contacted me to learn more about my trading experience and history in the markets so he could prepare properly and tailor the session to my needs. I can sometimes get nervous meeting new people, but Gary made me feel welcome and at ease immediately.

Right from the start, he reassured me that we would take as much time as needed to cover everything properly, and he stayed on the call well beyond our allotted time.
We went through an overall view of the markets, understanding how and why they move, before breaking down charts in detail and identifying key levels, reading market bias, and discussing appropriate stop placement. All of this was incredibly useful.

What stood out most to me, though, was that beyond the technical side of trading, Gary seemed genuinely interested in me as a person and in my progress. Many of us have probably been drawn in by sham “mentors” in the past who give very generic advice and treat people as just another number. This felt completely different. The session felt personal, genuine, and tailored specifically to me.

Now I just need to put into practice everything we discussed, but I wouldn’t hesitate to book another session in the future to review my progress and identify areas where I can improve further. I’d be 100% confident that I would get value from it again.

It was also extremely useful to receive a recording of the session afterwards so I can revisit it whenever I need to.

Gary is a highly skilled trader and educator. No BS and he really want to teach you. I recommend Gary to anyone who want to learn trading

If your wanting to trade seriously and not just to get rich quick, and willing to listen and put in the work, then this is the best mentor anyone could ask for … No BS straight to the point , so so many helpfull videos webinars and Scruff if the most generous man you will ever meet, he goes far and beyond if if believes you really want to succeed and put the effort in …

For me his my saving grace and i will be forever gratefull to have met him and been under his wing, his just an amazing person that’s so intelligent , straight to the point , likeable , funny , strict,, he just has it all , and his worth his weight in gold , and that’s quite allot becuase his 20 stone so enough said … Scruff i love you mate , forever gratefull to have met you mate. Dan Ferraro 🫡😉😊

A great teacher to help everyone that wants to learn trading, do not join or contact if you're expecting signals however if you want to learn a skill for life and trade yourself this is definitely the place to be

Highly recommend no bs straight to the point says it how it is if your after a lambo and a mansion in Dubai after a week keep dreaming the squads for people who want to learn the right way every trades different and every trader is no one trades the same find with alot of people it.s to easy to blame everyone else when stuff doesn't go right Gary's proves it works and his win rate backs it up learnt alot from the meeting now it.s down to me to put it all together appreciate the help and your time today carnt thank you enough today look forward to another meeting
thanks lee

If you want to become a trader — especially a full-time day trader — I highly recommend following The Way of the Scruff modules and joining the Discord community. I’ve been learning to trade for a few years now, and I’ve never come across anyone who explains every detail of the market from A to Z in such a clear, systematic way. This is, in my opinion, the only learning path you’ll ever need.

If you’re serious about trading and learning properly then look no further than Gary (Scruffy). Forget the rolex wearing, Lambo driving frauds on YouTube. Gary sells you nothing and if you’re willing to put the time and effort in he goes above and beyond to help guide you on your way.
There are currently 53 modules (The Way of the Scruff) which are packed with information and knowledge to set you on your way.
Joined the discord group which is full of great Guys n Girls who are all on the same journey. Not had a 1 to 1 yet but that’s next on the list.
Highly recommended….

I joined the Scruffy Squad in June this year (2025). I bought the 'Way of the Scruff' videos through the website and then joined the Scruffy Squad on YouTube once I'd worked my way through the modules a couple of times. (You can also just join the Scruffy Squad on YouTube and get instant access to the modules and 100s of other videos that way too.)

Since then my trading success has taken off like it has a rocket under it. I'd been trying without Scruff's guidance for a whole year before and was just breaking even and getting despondent, but with Scruff's solid advice, the step by step Way of the Scruff which teaches you to be a stand alone trader, not just follow a system dependent on subscriptions forever, plus a few 1-2-1s to sort out some errors I was making I'm now on an 80%+ win rate and am actually making money and have been for months. Good money too.

Being part of the Scruffy Squad is so important given how alone retail traders are. The shared knowledge is huge, as is the database of videos for pretty much any issue you can think of and someone always has the right question for what I was thinking in the interactive live Zoom calls (4 each week).

Gary/Scruff amazingly responds to every question, he often makes videos to reply and fully explains every trade set up and what he is doing. Complete transparency and honesty. He gives so much to the group in time and experience, as well as a healthy dose of humour that livens it up.

I've seen so many people in the group of different levels and experience all making progress, all pulling together and supporting one another. Its an amazing thing that Gary has built and the shocker is that its affordable to most, giving value way in excess of its monetary cost.

I would have zero hesitation in recommending joining the Scruffy Squad for anyone who wants to become a real trader with real realistic results. Ignore the wannabes who hire flash cars for YouTube videos and instead invest in yourself by choosing a real trader with 20 years experience, the ability to coach and mentor and verified success that he is happy to evidence. You won't look back.

I came across Gary about a year ago, and I can honestly say that joining the Scruffy Squad was one of the best decisions I have ever made. The knowledge and wisdom that he shares is second to none, and it's an absolute privilege to be able to call him my mentor. If you are willing to put the work in, then Gary will support you every step of the way. The community, live weekly calls and Members Only YouTube videos are worth their weight in gold, so if you want to learn from someone who has been there and done it with over 20 years of experience trading, then Gary is your man.

This Guy is the REAL DEAL. No pushing product or courses. Just a lazer focused on trading . He has over 20 years experience, where trading has been his sole income. He regularly shows his live trades and P&L. I have no doubt he genuinely, wants to help me . I came away from our One to One meeting. Fired up, knowing that with his expert mentoring and my hard work I now have a way forward .Big Thanks to the Big Fella.

I have been a squad member for 3 months now and am so impressed with the group. The information is well presented gary tells it as it is.
Had a 1 to 1 today and the information imparted was worth ten times what i paid. small errors i was making were pointed out , the whole structure of trading was shown and now feel 100% confident moving forward.

I joined the Scruffy Squad about a year ago after spending two years spinning my wheels with trading. After putting in the hours, watching Scruff’s content and really taking it in, I finally started to understand what it actually takes to be successful.

The community is spot on, people helping each other, sharing ideas, and working together on the same goal. There are some really great individuals in the group, and it makes the whole journey feel less lonely.

Scruff’s content is honest and no nonsense. He doesn’t push extra products or try to sell you the dream, it’s all real, practical, and grounded. He genuinely wants people to learn and succeed.

I’m really glad I stuck with it and found this. It’s made trading feel structured, realistic, and actually enjoyable again.

Cheers!

Trading is lonely and when you hit a down patch you can feel super isolated. I hit said down patch on my swing trading strategy.

What generally happens next is you doubt yourself throw out years of back testing and reasoning search you tube and invariably fall for the snake oil salesman with the Ferrari in his bio and the guarantees of 100000x return with a $1 account.

I've been down that road so generally I can sniff those out. My algo then sent me scruff. I popped him an email expecting a reply saying he could help me but it would cost X etc which is fair enough.

Well he replied and chatted with me and told me to hold the course effectively. The markets strange at the minute but if your system is tried and tested and most importantly your risk management is good you'll be fine..

Odd, no soliciting of business. Never had that before. This then made me realise he is as genuine as he comes across on you tube. I decided to join his group and have access to all his material for the exorbitant fee of £45!

This gives you access to all scruffs 50 well laid out modules.

I have friends and colleagues who have paid £3000 to £10000 for stuff that doesn’t come close to scruffs content.

His content is mainly centred around day trading. I'm not into day trading. I'm not built for it but his swing trading strategy which I think he should promote more is sound and I'm thoroughly back testing it on US stocks and its holding up very well.

Anyway, the part that no one want to hear and will invariably mean you won’t get to scruff until you've wasted 0000000s of £s on Ferrari educators is it’s not a signal service and its heavily focussed on risk management.

If you want to have any chance at success in trading, you need to work out how it works for you in your head and you need a SOLID risk management mindset. If you don’t have this you will fail.

Teaching someone how to trade is easy, teaching someone how to lose is the most difficult part of all.

Even a poor system has a chance with solid RM.

This is the key area with the way of the scruff.

It’s ridiculous that the guy only charges £49 for this and everything that goes with it. If you are new to trading then I would ask you join scruff. The learnings you will receive here will put you forward years.
I wish him all the best.

Just finished up a call with Gary - difficult to know how best to describe it as it accomplished so many things. I suppose in a nutshell, it gave me clarity, reassurance and imparted wisdom to me that simply cannot be gained through anything other than real competence and decades of experience - and most refreshingly, without ANY of the ego that goes along with speaking to a charlatan. We had a good laugh and the call didn't feel rushed. Gary was generous with his knowledge and also super courteous and thoughtful - and all his questions were asked in the pursuit of my greater wellbeing. A rare soul indeed, this chap. The consult fee goes to a great cause. I can't speak highly enough about the experience. I'd recommend it to everyone - except I realise so much of this will fall on deaf ears. Those who are looking for easy money without the work, those who have no interest in self-mastery and take no accountability for their decisions and actions (which accounts for most people)... won't realise what gold is found here. In summary, I have a lot of time for Gary, and he's one of the most generous fellas I've ever met in terms of his willingness to share something that's so closely guarded and so valuable to so many. Thanks mate!

Just Had a one to one with Gary (Scruffy)
What a pleasure, A Top Man who knows his stuff inside out, Gives a no BS approach to explaining his Trading Experience and Routine. He went above and beyond with his time, and it's really helped me going forward with my trading,
Looking forward to the next one.