Failed warranty 19 yrs into 50 yr product
Approximately 40 squares of Certainteed Weatherwood Shingles of 50 yr warranty class 4 were installed January 2007. The install was text book and has held up very well. No issues with the ridge vents, powered vent housings (motor replacements every 4-7 years from attic-no roof disturbance), flashings or gutters. Shingles were subject to several storms in south east Houston from 2007 to current and we did not experience lifted shingles or vents blown off. Not water intrusion.
However, I requested a premium product, upgrading to the 50 yr, Class 4 shingle. While I did not calculate value of the warranty over time, I figured the roof I have today would not be at the 19 yr mark. I thought the condition of the roof might look it does at age 35 or 40, not 19 years.
Roofers evaluated the roof according to Certainteed’s warranty requirements, removing a sample, which was sent in for evaluation. Fibers are showing from the exposed edges of the shingles, rock is missing and shingles are brittle. The warranty offer from Certainteed would not cover ¼ replacement material. They did offer a discount of 5% if I purchase more Certainteed shingles to replace but of course no additional funds or discounts for labor, underlayment, ridge vents or other components.
19 years into a 50 year life and the shingles are eligible for warranty payment. Photos show rock missing on many shingles, fibers exposed and material drying and cracking. The roof is severely degraded for its age and I am having to budget for replacement much sooner than expected. I can’t imagine this roof lasting another 10 years with so much rock and asphalt material missing. I offered to purchase 50% material from a local installer if Certainteed would provide the remaining 50% shingles, but they refused referring to the original warranty from 2005-2006 date of manufacture, a time period known for class action suits against shingle products. Very little value is added by choosing a product beyond a base product warranty. I can’t imagine a 10 year product looking this warn after 4-1/2 years.
Home insurance raises rates greatly increase premiums after a roof becomes 10 years of age, so it may be a better cost measure to replace shingles every ten years, buying the cheapest product one the market in the hope insurance rates will stay low.
2. huhtikuuta 2026
Oma-aloitteinen arvostelu